Delicious!!! for two, we got the small Greek salad & a large NY Cappy Pizza! The salad is a 10/10 and they are generous with the serving sizes! The waitress was also very kind. The atmosphere is so fun! Parking on a Sunday evening was a slight challenge.
Sara Elizabeth
-
October 05, 2026
Cappy’s is so delicious- I love the Cappy’s style (+ banana peppers) on both the deep dish and NY style. I get both because I can’t choose one, and the smalls are very nice size Portions. I am a big chicago lou malnati’s deep dish pizza fan and Cappy’s brings that same delish flavor to the table! This is much better than any NY pizza I’ve had there in my opinion. Plus so reasonably priced as well - definitely my go to for pizza takeout night.
Michael Rivera
-
May 18, 2026
Came here to Cappy’s for the first time hungryyyy after a day of filming. Pizza was on my mind and not just any pizza a Gooood NY still pizza. Being from BROOKLYN finding a good pizza spot is hard. But Cappys didn’t disappoint. I got the NY style pizza with onions, green peppers and banana peppers And yeah it was great. Check pics for the cheese pull haha only thing I would’ve asked for is a little more sauce on the pizza but that’s just personal preference. They don’t have any dessert which was a bummer but besides that 10/10
Ovi
-
September 27, 2025
From the moment we walked in, Cappy’s Pizza delivered an experience that was both delicious and delightful. The service was top-notch—our server, Venessa, was incredibly sweet and attentive, making sure we felt welcome and well taken care of throughout the meal.
The Cappy pizza itself was outstanding. You can truly taste the difference in their ingredients—everything was fresh, vibrant, and full of flavor. Each bite had that perfect balance of crisp crust, rich sauce, and generous toppings that felt thoughtfully chosen.
Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Cappy’s is a must-visit for anyone who appreciates great food and genuine hospitality. We’ll definitely will be back
Hien Loc
-
September 29, 2026
The food is still great, and my husband and I really enjoy coming here. However, this time we were served dirty plates at our table. We asked for clean ones, but the replacements still looked dirty, stick dried food there , as if they had not been washed properly. My concern is whether the dishes are being cleaned and sanitized properly. I hope the restaurant can pay more attention to hygiene and cleanliness because this is important for customers’ health
Our Address
3200 W Bay to Bay Blvd, Tampa, FL 33629, USA
Claim Listing: Cappys Pizzeria
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
Delicious!!! for two, we got the small Greek salad & a large NY Cappy Pizza! The salad is a 10/10 and they are generous with the serving sizes! The waitress was also very kind. The atmosphere is so fun! Parking on a Sunday evening was a slight challenge.
Cappy’s is so delicious- I love the Cappy’s style (+ banana peppers) on both the deep dish and NY style. I get both because I can’t choose one, and the smalls are very nice size Portions. I am a big chicago lou malnati’s deep dish pizza fan and Cappy’s brings that same delish flavor to the table! This is much better than any NY pizza I’ve had there in my opinion. Plus so reasonably priced as well - definitely my go to for pizza takeout night.
Came here to Cappy’s for the first time hungryyyy after a day of filming. Pizza was on my mind and not just any pizza a Gooood NY still pizza. Being from BROOKLYN finding a good pizza spot is hard. But Cappys didn’t disappoint. I got the NY style pizza with onions, green peppers and banana peppers And yeah it was great. Check pics for the cheese pull haha only thing I would’ve asked for is a little more sauce on the pizza but that’s just personal preference. They don’t have any dessert which was a bummer but besides that 10/10
From the moment we walked in, Cappy’s Pizza delivered an experience that was both delicious and delightful. The service was top-notch—our server, Venessa, was incredibly sweet and attentive, making sure we felt welcome and well taken care of throughout the meal. The Cappy pizza itself was outstanding. You can truly taste the difference in their ingredients—everything was fresh, vibrant, and full of flavor. Each bite had that perfect balance of crisp crust, rich sauce, and generous toppings that felt thoughtfully chosen. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Cappy’s is a must-visit for anyone who appreciates great food and genuine hospitality. We’ll definitely will be back
The food is still great, and my husband and I really enjoy coming here. However, this time we were served dirty plates at our table. We asked for clean ones, but the replacements still looked dirty, stick dried food there , as if they had not been washed properly. My concern is whether the dishes are being cleaned and sanitized properly. I hope the restaurant can pay more attention to hygiene and cleanliness because this is important for customers’ health